1989
    January 1989
        Choral and Song
                Stravinsky Pulcinella. Jeu de cartes.
  

Stravinsky Pulcinella—ballet (rev. 1947) a. Jeu de cartes. a Teresa Berganza (mez); a Ryland Davies (ten); a John Shirley-Quirk (bar); London Symphony Orchestra / Claudio Abbado.

DG Galleria (Mid  price) (Cassette) 423 889-4GGA; (CD) 423 889-2GGA (62 minutes: ADD). Text and translation included. Item marked a from 2531 087 (6/79), b 2530 537 (8/57).

Pulcinella—selected CD comparison:
Smith, Fryatt, King, N. Sinf, Rattle (9/88) CDM7 69204-2

Abbado conducts Pulcinella with a good deal of vigour, persuading his smallish group from the LSO to some very adroit, nimble playing. Tempos are generally pretty swift and the performance as a whole is most exhilarating. Teresa Berganza's warmth of tone and vivid musical personality are a joy to hear, but all the solo singing is good. On a rival middisc from EMI, Simon Rattle finds a little more wit and elegance in the score, but his soloists are no more than competent and his fill-up of the two Suites is less generous than that of the DG.

Abbado directs a very crisp, clear and well-balanced account of Jeu de cartes, with confident high-spirited playing and hardly a ragged edge anywhere. If the LSO's sharpness of attack and rhythmic security are impressive then so is their playing in the quieter passages of the score, which are realized with a good deal of finesse. The recording of Jeu de cartes is a little more natural and vivid than that of Pulcinella, but the quality in both scores is more than satisfactory.

AS