|
| EMI (Full price) (CD) CDC7 54138-2 (56 minutes:
DDD). |
|
|
| Clarinet Concertoselected comparison: |
|
|
| Brymer, RPO, Beecham (7/91) CDZ7 67007-2 |
|
|
| Sinfonia concertanteselected
comparisons: |
|
|
| London CO, Warren-Green (9/89) VC7 90818-2 |
|
|
| Orpheus CO (4/91) 429 784-2GH |
|
It makes sense to play Mozart's Clarinet Concerto
on the instrument for which it was writtenthe basset clarinet which extended the
range of a modern clarinet in A down by four semitones to the A at the bottom of the bass
clef, the keynote that Mozart chose for that very reason; though the original score has
not survived, it is clear enough when the extra low notes are needed and the result is
very satisfying. Sabine Meyer is one of Germany's best young players, and she gives a very
fluent and pleasing account of this work while still not, in my view, plumbing all its
expressive depths.
The first movement is taken fairly briskly, but
there is no harm in that; I am not sure, though, that the Adagio here, gentle and
mellifluous though it is, will altogether satisfy collectors who possess, or remember,
richer and more caressing performances of this sublime music. Those looking for one will
probably not go wrong with the celebrated if elderly account by Jack Brymer, Sir Thomas
Beecham and the RPO, now available on a budget EMI disc, although for my own taste the
conducting is heavyish. Few, however, will find fault with the present elegant version of
the dancelike finale in 6/8. Certainly the work is very expertly performed, while the
orchestral playing, both here and in the Sinfonia concertante, matches that of the
soloists; the recording, too, is satisfying.
The three soloists who join Meyer in the Sinfonia
concertante in E flat major are members of the recently founded Sabine Meyer Wind
Ensemble. The work is certainly not authentic, as the booklet essay rightly spells out,
though Mozart undoubtedly wrote such a piece. Whatever the case, it is most agreeable and
the performance is equally attractive. It is well-paced and well-blended as well as
bringing out the essential geniality of the invention, while the final variation movement
has delightful wit. In this work there is strong competition, notably from the unfailingly
stylish Orpheus Chamber Orchestra on DG and the skilful and richly recorded London Chamber
Orchestra (Virgin Classics). But if the Clarinet Concerto as it is played here suits you,
this disc is recommendable.
CH