|
| Virgin Classics Veritas (Full price) (CD) VC5
45010-2 (67 minutes: DDD). |
|
|
| Standage, AAM, Hogwood (4/92) (L'OI) 433
045-2OH2 |
|
These fresh, appealing performances stand up well
in an awesomely crowded field. With her gut-strung Amati, Monica Huggett does not, of
course, rival modern-instrument virtuosos like Grumiaux, Szeryng and Perlman in brilliance
and dynamic range. But these concertos gain much from her sweet, slender tone, her light,
buoyant articulation and her beautiful control of colour in piano dynamics. The
passagework in the opening movements of the first two concertos can often seem tedious in
high-powered traditional performances; but the lighter period bow and Huggett's deft
touches of timing and shading invariably lend wit and point to Mozart's sequences of
triplets and semiquavers. The finales of both these concertos are delightfully lithe and
airy, while the closing minuet of No. 5 is unusually delicatethough there is plenty
of gusto in the A minor 'Turkish' episode (from 3'59"). In the three slow movements
other performances may be more overtly expressive, freer with rubato; but Huggett's purity
and poise, her subtle graduations of vibrato and her gentle eloquence of phrase are very
persuasive. At one or two points I thought her line over-inflected with dynamic nuances:
in her first entry in No. 1's Adagio, for example (1'08"), she crescendos into
each of the longer notes, with slightly fussy effect. Here and occasionally elsewhere I
would have preferred a broader, simpler line.
These new performances share with the rival
period readings from Simon Standage (available on a L'Oiseau-Lyre two-disc set of all five
concertos) a keen feeling for the music's dance rhythms and a sure sense of style in
cadenzas (aptly brief) and ornamentation. The orchestral contribution in both versions,
too, is crisp, transparent and nicely detailed. Standage is generally the more assertive
player, brighter of tone, sharper of attack. A movement like the opening Allegro aperto
of No. 5 is rather more consciously projected from Standage; Huggett, at a slower tempo,
is more intimate and understated, with a more refined tonal paletteI especially
liked her veiled timbre at the first solo entry (1'20"). The final minuet of the same
concerto brings a similar contrast between the two players; and if Standage tends to draw
a longer legato line in the slow movements, his playing here, particularly in K219, can
seem a shade unvaried, lacking Huggett's tenderness and imagination. Huggett, too, has the
edge in purity of intonation. I should certainly not want to be without Standage's more
eager, extrovert performances. But forced to choose one period version of these three
concertos my vote would now go to Huggett, captured in clear, warm sound, with a natural
balance between soloist and orchestra.
RW