GramoFile on the Web
Bach [Concerto] Concertos for Violin and Strings a —A, BWV1052; F minor, BWV1056. Concerto for Oboe, Violin and Strings in C minor, BWV1060 b. Concerto for Oboe d'amore and Strings in A, BWV1055 c. Anthony Robson ( bc ob/ c dir); Elizabeth Wallfisch ( a vn/ ab dir); Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment
Virgin Classics Veritas (Full price) (CD) VC5 45095-2 (60 minutes: DDD).
Violin [Concerto] Concertos, BWV1052 and 1056—selected comparison:
Standage, Collegium Musicum 90 (5/93) (CHAN) CHAN0530

It seems strange that Bach, a keyboardist par excellence, produced his harpsichord concertos by converting existing (now 'lost') concertos for other solo instruments rather than by starting from scratch, but the evidence is strong enough to have convinced so many musicological courts that it now seems beyond contradiction. These reconstructed concertos have for the most part served as 'fillers' (the three 'basic' violin concertos don't add up to an adequate CD) or in mixed programmes such as that of Standage and Collegium Musicum 90; here they constitute the programme. Call me a Philistine if you like, but I find these reconstructions more satisfying than the works from which they are derived, largely because the balance between soloist(s) and orchestra is more even—the harpsichord is too often difficult to hear clearly in both concert and recording situations.

Elizabeth Wallfisch's chamber-musical reputation is well established, and in her recording of Vivaldi's Four Seasons (Meridian, 10/90) she showed herself to be a fine concerto soloist; here I find her no less impressive. Her incisiveness and three-dimensional tone (the proportions of which she skilfully varies) suit this music admirably, and there is sensitivity in her treatment of the slow movements, notably in the Largo of BWV1056, where she eschews the harpsichord's 'busier' ornamentation, leaving the violin to sing its sad song with dignity. The performances of Anthony Robson and the OAE are in every way of comparable quality, and if I say no more of them it is because I have reached the end of the space allowed for the review of this comprehensively outstanding recording. Do not miss it!
JD