|
| Collins Classics (Full price) (CD) 1081-2 (two
discs, nas: 146 minutes: DDD). |
|
The young British cellist, Robert Cohen, plays a
modern instrumentactually it dates from 1692 but is strung and otherwise modified to
present-day requirementsand draws a warm, resonant sound from it. His approach to
these great works follows the tradition established by Casals and maintained in various
ways and in varying degrees by generations of cellists since. Cohen's performances have
many virtues, among the greatest of them to my mind being a complete absence of empty
virtuosity and intrusive showmanship. This is serious playing which makes a real attempt
to reach the heart of the music without the aid of artifice, flamboyance or an excess of
personal mannerism. His choice of tempo is invariably unhurried and he is not afraid to
take more time over a piece, even than Casals if he feels that it is justified. Cohen has
a nice feeling for phrases which he articulates and punctuates effectively. In short, he
gives the music shape and character with a very well-controlled bowing arm and an
intuitive sense of where best to place emphasis.
The Courante of the Suite No. 3 in C major is a
good example of how engagingly he presents the music when all these fine qualities in his
playing come together. Sarabandes, without exception, are executed with sustained
gracefulness and are taken at a slower tempo than almost any other version I know. That in
itself might imply a degree of ennui, but in fact quite the reverse is the case. Cohen's
technique enables him to play these deeply expressive movements with admirable control;
phrases and sustained notes sing out eloquently, often sounding an unusually deep note of
pathos. That quality extends furthermore to some of the little 'galanteries' such as the
Bourree II of the Suite in C major. Allemandes and Courantes come over with a pleasing
feeling for gesture, and are both clearly and effectively punctuated. Cohen's playing of
the Gigues which conclude each Suite is motivated in a lively way, though here I sometimes
felt they were just a little too weighty and a little too emphatic; that of the D minor is
too aggressive for me, and the playing is less tidy here than elsewhere.
What of the Preludes, which reveal so much of a
player's imagination and sense of fantasy? Cohen takes a leisurely and expansive view of
these, imbuing them with rhythmic suppleness and a poetic sense of improvisatory freedom;
the D minor Prelude from Suite No. 2 is magnificently done with a brooding intensity that
I have seldom before heard. I should have liked him to linger just a fraction longer on
the radiant high G, the climax of an upward semiquaver journey towards the end of the G
major Prelude from Suite No. 1, but the journey itself is rewarding in this performance.
This playing of Bach's unaccompanied cello suites
is impressive. Intonation is secure and, as I say, Cohen's tone is satisfying. Vibrato is
kept under the strictest supervision and all repeats are observed. Such virtues on their
own do not make fine performances, but Cohen in addition has imagination, and a good sense
of style. With performances such as those of Casals (EMI), Fournier (DG), Tortelier (EMI)
and Bylsma (RCA) in the catalogue the new set meets with formidable competition, yet few
of their adherents could fail to be impressed by playing of this order. Fine recorded
sound.
NA