|
| Decca digital (Full price) (LP) 414 290-1DH
(Cassette) 414 290-4DH (CD) 414 290-2DH. |
|
|
| Concertgebouw, Haitink (9/67) (2/85R) 412
359-1PS. |
|
|
| BPO, Karajan (4/78) 2707 102. |
|
|
| Concertgebouw, Haitink (1/80) 6769 028. |
|
Riccardo Chailly's interpretation of Bruckner's
Seventh takes insidious hold of the listener. A first hearing, I warn you, may prove
disappointing, perhaps because too many other performances are cluttered in the mind. But
play it again, especially on CD (the only version so far to hand on this carrier) when
there is no irritating break in the Adagio, and aspects of a deeply-felt
Brucknerian experience come increasingly to the fore. The orchestra may not be warmed by
the acoustic glow which irradiates Karajan's Berlin Philharmonic on DG, but it makes a
splendid sound, with ringing brass, supple woodwind and keen strings. The coda of the Adagio
is most beautifully played, the solo flute heard as if in a trance, and the wonderful
opening of the whole work rises out of the murmuration of strings with a Parsifal-like
grace and ecstasy. Karajan here is more 'inward', Haitink on his 1980 Philips two-LP (and
better) Concertgebouw set more consciously reverent.
Chailly's tempo for this opening is slightly
broader than either and he takes longer over each movement. Yet he never lets the music
drag nor risks its becoming ponderous; and this stems from his concern for the textures in
Bruckner. Those who find Karajan's approach a little too 'velvety' will enjoy Chailly's
revelations of the structural muscularity and fibre of this symphony as well as of its
rolling harmonic landscapes. Haitink's one-LP 1967 version (also on Philips) is a bargain
at mid-price. Anyone reluctant to invest in a full-price two-LP Seventh, with the Siegfried
idyll as fill-up in both instances, will not regret plumping for the Chailly, which is
good musical and economic value (and, as I have said, so far the only CD version submitted
for review).
MK