|
| Arte Nova Classics (Super budget price) (CD)
74321 59226-2 (46 minutes: DDD). |
|
|
| Chicago SO, Solti (4/96) (DECC) 448 898-2DH |
|
|
| VPO, Abbado (5/97) (DG) 453 415-2GH |
|
It was Skrowaczewskis remarkable Halle
recording of Bruckners Fourth Symphony (Carlton, 3/94) which first alerted me to his
qualities as a Brucknerian, fiery and impassioned, with an ability (not given to all
Bruckner conductors on record) to get an orchestra to play as if it knew the music
inside out. How well the Saarbrucken RSO knows the First Symphony (the original Linz
version) I wouldnt dare to speculate. That said, this terrifically fiery 1995
recording is fervent and affectionate by turns, the rustic vigour of the demonstrably
skilful Saarbrucken playing everywhere apt to the spirit of this rumbustious and songful jeu
desprit.
The recording is excellent, as attentive to
Bruckners quaint descants as it is to the main matter on the agenda. Would that the
editing were as good. An unearthly screech from goodness knows where in bar 55 of the Scherzo
(1'30") recurs during the repeat (2'40"), calling to mind Lady Bracknells
all too frequently quoted line about one such instance being accounted a misfortune, a
second looking like carelessness. Rank carelessness in the case of a super-budget version
that might otherwise have had would-be collectors wondering whether or not to spend that
additional tenner on one or other of the excellent versions listed above.
RO